/ in Perspectives in Education / by
Last modified on:

Myths of Gifted Children

Myths of Gifted Children
By Todd Stanley

There is a myth that surrounds the gifted child. A lot of these myths are created by the way popular culture represents giftedness. A movie that came out last year was Gifted with Chris Evans. It is the story about a kindergartner who can do college level math and beyond. Other popular movies and television such as Rain Main, Good Will Hunting, and Monk show people with gifts that allow them to do special things such as to solve crimes. There is even a television show on Fox called The Gifted which is about mutants with super powers that act as their gifts. The problem with these representations is that that giftedness becomes like a gimmick, so when we are faced with a real gifted child, we expect them to do unrealistic, amazing things like some sort of parlor trick. 

There are many myths about gifted children but here are ten of the more common ones:

  1. Gifted children will succeed in life no matter what

This one can be problematic because if one believes this, as many do, the thinking becomes that gifted children do not need any specialized education aimed at their abilities. What then happens is the gifted child becomes bored because he is not being challenged and becomes turned off by school. 

  1. Gifted children love school and get high grades

What it should read is gifted children love to learn. The problem is that sometimes, what children want to learn and what school is offering can be two very different things. If a child is not willing to play the game of school, the grades might not reflect his ability. 

  1. Gifted children are good at everything they do

This false assumption can cause unreal expectations. There are some children who are very good at some subject areas but not so hot at others. The math whiz who always seems ahead of everyone else does poorly in social studies because he does not like to read. We cannot assume that just because a child has the label of gifted that he excels at all subject areas. 

  1. Gifted children have trouble socially at school fitting in

The myth prevails that all gifted children are nerdy and as a result, are socially awkward and have trouble making friends. Just like all kids, gifted children come in all shapes and sizes. What causes some of this awkwardness is that in the United States, we group children together based not on their abilities but by their age. Most children enter kindergarten when they are around six years of age and progress up the ladder with other children their same age. The problem with this is that those who have higher ability might have difficulty finding peers amongst the children their age. 

  1. Gifted children tend to be more mature than other kids their age

Many gifted children are more mature than other kids their age. That does not mean though they are ready to have mature conversations that children a few years older than them are having. Emotionally they are still the age on their birth certificate. They might be able to talk about quantum physics but still throw a fit when things do not go their way. No matter how smart they appear to be, it is important not to forget they are children.  

  1. Gifted children are always well-behaved and compliant 

On the contrary, some gifted children can come across as trouble makers because they are questioning things. This might be something the teacher said, some policy at the school, or some comment a fellow student has made. Their minds are designed to question things and sometimes these powers can be used for evil as well as good. In addition, if a gifted child becomes bored, he might misbehave because he does not have anything else to do.  

  1. Gifted children’s innate curiosity causes them to be self-directed

There are skills that are natural to students and there are others which have to be learned. If you assume that gifted children are self-directed and you turn them loose on a project, you might be surprised. This sometimes can mask itself because a child might be motivated about something in particular so she works tirelessly on it. Motivated and self-directed are not necessarily the same. Some gifted students will be motivated because of their curiosity and will do the work because it is exciting or fun. However, there will come a time when this curiosity wains, especially as the gifted child learns more and more and things are not so new, and getting her to do classroom tasks can be a challenge. Being self-directed means doing things you are not motivated by but you know it needs done. This is a learned skill. 

  1. All children are gifted

There are some who are opponents to giftedness because what it means to them is by saying these children are gifted, is that other children are not gifted. It is making a child feel as though he is not special and we do not want anyone to feel that way in our land of equity. Let us not forget that being identified as gifted is not for the purposes of social status, it is not a pat on the shoulder, it is not a reward. The purpose for the identification of gifted children is it allows school districts to determine what services would be best for those children, just as if a child were to be identified as learning disabled, the district would do the same. 

  1. All gifted children are quirky

Those who have taught gifted children for any amount of time recognize that some of their students have certain quirks. This could be such things as a lack of social awareness, a tendency toward perfectionism, becoming stressed about seemingly small things, worrying about problems half-way across the globe, or the over-excitabilities talked about in chapter 1. If you are going to teach gifted children it just becomes standard practice that you learn to accept these quirks as a part of doing business. These quirks can sometimes make a child stand out from the rest of the class, especially if she is in a regular education classroom. These quirks become more the norm in a program will all gifted children because more children have them so it does not stand out so much. 

  1. Special education children cannot be gifted

Special education and gifted seem to be on opposite ends of the spectrum, and yet there are those children known as twice exceptional or 2E. This is a child who has been identified as gifted but also has been diagnosed with a learning disability such as ADHD, dyslexia, emotional disturbance, or autism. Servicing this child can be very challenging because you have to feed both ends of the spectrum. There has to be enough challenge to satiate this child’s desire to learn while giving them enough support to help him to succeed. It is a tricky balancing act and one that is not always done well. 

Understanding that these are myths can go a long way in helping teachers to have a better understanding of who they are working with and how to best challenge them. Like most myths, there are glimpses of truth to some, but to make a blanket statement that all gifted children are like this is to suggest that all gifted children are the same. That would not be true of any group of students. In reality, gifted children are just like your typical child with the same needs and wants. However, their potential is the true gift, so trying to find ways to tap into this and use it to the best of the ability is the challenge of many teachers and parents of gifted.  

Todd Stanley is a National Board teacher and the author of many teacher-education books including Project-Based Learning for Gifted Students: A Handbook for the 21stCentury Classroom, When Smart Kids Underachieve in the Classroom: Practical Solutions for Teachers, and his latest Authentic Learning: Real World Experiences that Build 21stCentury Skills. He served as a classroom teacher for 18 years where he worked with parents to create two gifted programs for Reynoldsburg Schools as well as serving as their gifted coordinator for two years. He is currently the gifted services coordinator for Pickerington Local Schools where he lives with his wife and two daughters. You can follow him on Twitter @the_gifted_guy or visit his website at thegiftedguy.com where you can access blogs, resources, and view presentations he has given concerning gifted education, many which can be accessed at MyEdExpert.com.


Post preview

You Can’t Spell SCHOOL Without FUN

OK, you CAN spell SCHOOL without "fun" but who would want to?  One of the many sessions that podcast guest Dr. Katie…

Is Remediation Fixing Our Kids…Or Breaking Them?

Is Remediation Fixing Our Kids…Or Breaking Them? By Suzy Pepper Rollins If we could just fix our kids by plugging…